The title of this post is an age-old philosophical question, but I think it’s good to ask ourselves this question from time to time. Particularly as dance becomes a more common element in mass media, it’s important to think about what we value in dance and in art. Some might argue with even the practice of putting labels on things, but this is a blog about dance, I am passionate about dance, and given that, there are obviously some boundaries in my mind as to what constitutes dance and what does not.
I also ask, is all dance art? And if all dance is art, then how do we classify movement that is not art? What is art?
The source of all this soul-searching was this video that Loren sent me:
Without question, this is an incredible video. According to YouTube, these are the 100 dancers and acrobats of the Great Chinese State Circus; I believe the title for the work would be “Swan Lake on LSD.”
The ballet in this is not bad at all. Very technically proficient, and beautiful lines. I can’t fathom the amount of center and control it takes to dance en pointe on that guys’s head and shoulders while he is walking around. The frogs were very frog-like and very entertaining. But I ask, if all the acrobatics and head pointe dancing were taken out, would this video have had over 3.3 million hits on youtube? More importantly, would it be seen as anything special by dance and art lovers, other than another nice execution of swan lake?
Are acrobatics dance? Are acrobatics art? The following video of the Pilobolus “Dance Company” (I’ve added the quotation marks, more on that later) made me ask those two questions when I first saw it on Ariel’s blog:
For me, this is definitely art– a fantastically creative and sculptural treatment of the human body. But I’m not so sure that it’s dance. To me it falls more into the categories of acrobatics and contortionism. Yes Pilobolus calls itself a dance company. Is that because it holds that movement + art = dance? Yet take some of the mindless pap you see on shows like Dancing With the Stars…it’s definitely dance, but it sure ain’t art. At least not in my book. Even on the shows I enjoy, such as So You Think You Can Dance, acrobatics are often thrown in the mix in order to pander to attention-deficient viewers who need explosive movements and crazy physical feats to hold their attention. The line between dance and acrobatics is often blurred, as is the line between what I consider art and what I would not consider art, but nonetheless find fun and entertaining.
25 comments
Comments feed for this article
May 24, 2008 at 5:04 pm
Alex
Fantastic post, I think that the best forms of dance are the ones which allow creative self expression – like belly dancing.
May 24, 2008 at 6:07 pm
Anna Brady Nuse
I recently read somewhere that entertainment tells you what you already know and art is about what you don’t know. This seems to speak to the feeling that entertainment is reassuring, familiar, and spectacular. It’s all the surface of things. Art on the other hand, delves below the surface and tackles paradox and often raises more questions than provides answers. I think that there is a line between entertainment and art, but I’m not sure if there is a line between movement and dance, or acrobatics and dance. To me dance could be any movement, its simply in the eye of the beholder (or body of the mover). Dance is a gigantic container, and it could fall in either the entertainment camp, the art camp, or the ritual/folk camp. The thing to remember is that it is all subjective.
May 25, 2008 at 8:25 am
dancekitty
Really interesting post, this is such a sticky question, for me it is especially interesting to hear what people day when you ask if gymnastics used in dance is art. To me everything is dance and art, that is a touch abstract, but I tend be post-modern philosophically speaking. Thanks again for your post, cheers.
May 25, 2008 at 11:58 am
Art or Not? « Dance Advantage
[…] competition, dance, public | A Time to Dance recently featured a post titled “What is dance and what makes it art?.“ I just wanted to share this thoughtful post and its thoughtful responses, plus add my […]
May 26, 2008 at 9:25 pm
Loren
It’s fascinating to me where you went with this. Do you think that acrobatic dance can be art and dance? I do, but I don’t believe this one was well integrated. Very showy, but not really Swan Lake… But then that raises the question of what is good art? And given that I personally love to perform, and hope some consider it dance and art, but… the quality of my technique leaves much to be desired, I’m not sure I want to go there .
Keep writing, keep thinking, keep dancing! Thanks, Maria.
June 3, 2008 at 4:54 pm
Camille
I agree a lot with Anna’s comment. I just want to add that I think all sorts of movement can be considered dance depending on the intent given. A lot of obvious distinctions between an artist and an entertainer in the dance world can be seen with this factor as well. Intent is key for me. Seeing and feeling the thought behind the movement becomes a power to transform otherwise ordinary movement into art.
April 17, 2009 at 3:34 pm
Art or Not? | Dance Advantage
[…] regular updates.Powered by WP Greet BoxA Time to Dance recently featured a post titled “What is dance and what makes it art?.” I just wanted to share this thoughtful post and its thoughtful responses, plus add my […]
April 21, 2011 at 4:22 am
smriti
for me dance is one of the most exquisite form of art . It accelerates the proper growth of human body, removes the extra flab and makes a vibrant personality .
January 27, 2012 at 8:27 pm
kevin
dance is with in everybody that moves to music to me everyone can dance i see everything as a movement no matter what and anyone that say you can not dance is not seeing the real you if however they are looking for what they believe is dance then everyone is in for a shock
August 14, 2012 at 7:25 am
John
Dance is an attempt to achieve perfect harmony between music and the body. It is beautiful to watch and to experience oneself, which makes it a unique form of art.
November 3, 2012 at 4:20 am
jbuenavia
dah wat ever
November 9, 2012 at 5:08 pm
guy
Thank you very much!
January 8, 2013 at 1:49 am
Kelly omorefe
I luv dancing thanks for d enlightenment
April 5, 2013 at 9:30 am
online casinos for free
With all the wide selection of game titles to help tickle my fancy along with to be able to test the game titles and never have to spend an individual
dime our expertise ended up being quite enjoyable.
Be sure to operate the unique not any put in advantage
signal 10 to supply these an attempt about the Casino’s penny. The idea form of takes your exciting out of it, although each of our lead to hand will get a bit exhausted every once in awhile. By doing this, whenever you exploit the not any down payment extra, you may be rest assured upon entering each of our put in within your consideration after we confirm the cards to help you to possibly be up and actively playing exactly the same day time.
April 8, 2013 at 5:57 pm
Find Out More
An attention-grabbing discussion is worth comment. I feel that you should write extra on this matter, it may not be a taboo topic however typically individuals are not sufficient to talk on such topics. To the next. Cheers
April 9, 2013 at 11:11 pm
christian louboutin fifi
I¡¦ve learn several excellent stuff here. Definitely value bookmarking for revisiting. I wonder how much effort you place to create any such great informative website.
April 16, 2013 at 4:49 pm
high noon online casino
The particular high noon online casino offes the many delightful video games including B6 Baccarat, Small Baccarat, blackjack, high noon online casino Battle etc.
The primary type of gambling web page usually uses Adobe
flash or perhaps Shockwave, which often permits the item to operate with your
web browser. Simply because you’ll find a lot fewer approaches to make a direct together with 3 playing cards compared to a flush, straights position greater.
June 25, 2013 at 6:27 pm
box24 casino online Slots
Consequently even though you drop a little, think about
the expence being a small payment for just a properly put
in night. Several gamers will enjoy and play till they manage up to now in to the reddish colored, many people develop
financial difficulties pertaining to them selves in addition to their loved ones.
June 28, 2013 at 2:21 am
box24 casino online slots
talent if you believe it good, determine bingo with the degree of improvement of which from just about every phase will adjust the type of your respective
mind-set with the online game. On-line gambling is a lot easier versus
classic process connected with inserting gamble.
July 4, 2013 at 9:09 am
optionxp
optionxp gives you over a person invested, assisting you to inside using your own first knowledge just as one trader and comprehending that you’ll help to make mistakes as you go along which can be normal for all newcomers. Not like an average futures agreement which in turn involves someone to take delivery on the merchandise at a future time, optionxp tend to be including insurance coverage, certainly where an high quality can be settled a great choice seller for that to certainly buy, or maybe market, the futures agreement at the particular price tag. Although optionxp can be quite a extremely fast strategy to acquire, as well as lose, your hard earned dollars, that isn’t going to imply
trading on this sector can be fake in any way. These kind of feature’s include “Auto-trade”, allowing you investors to create a similar deal around all 5 effective occasions and also the “Close” and “Extend” optionxp that provides buyers the option to help close up a profitable business first to cut back losing as well as to improve the expiry moment to be able to improve help. On the other hand, by pursuing current trends, along with acquiring start opportunities having optionxp towards the actual trend, this likelihood involving discovering large gains is unquestionably in your favor.
July 6, 2013 at 4:12 pm
optionbit
Maybe you have to set up a large amount of cash termed
some sort of “margin” so that you can control many of the
optionbit that you just purchase. Sad to say, the world just isn’t excellent, and you may encounter losses along the route. If you would want to have an advantages whenever investing optionbit, among the finest ways to strengthen your own ability to include earning investments is actually to look at monetary indications.
July 13, 2013 at 5:16 pm
optionbit
Obviously, this isn’t a regular career in which an individual show up and also a paycheck will probably like magic , look. As you can view, optionbit give a high potential for creating a profit with no every one of the pitfalls normally regarding purchasing assets or maybe commodities. Also, if you try to find a placed solution, and also the market sets, you can yet again earn 70% of your respective preliminary expenditure.
April 11, 2015 at 9:06 am
LIVE LOVE DANCING! | diminishingboredom
[…] long time studying it seems that the simplest way to energize my body and to start over again is to dance.Dancing is an art, I’m not a professional but at the same time I know how to live the music. […]
April 18, 2015 at 3:27 am
Crazy Party | diminishingboredom
[…] in this field is wide. Every summer and mostly once per month we plan for a party full with joy, dancing, laughing, eating, and singing…. One of the most unforgettable parties that I have […]
February 13, 2020 at 8:10 am
The Debate: Is Dance a Sport or an Art?
[…] to argue that classical productions don't tug on people's hearts or that a provocative modern dance piece holds no significance at all. So, is dance an art, a sport, or a combination of […]